Return of the Cat?
Courtesy of Sunday's New York Times, we have a report on the next frontier for mobile phones... enhanced bar code scanning functions. The Times even included a sidebar with instructions on how to activate the functionality on many phones. Honestly, I would have written this off as another April Fools prank (like Google's tradition of poking fun at itself), except that I actually recognize the new jack codes from overnight delivery packages. (Engadget weighs in with a heavy thumb on the snark scale and gets somewhat rebuffed by its own commenters.)
Here's the odd part -- absolutely no mention of the :CueCat in the entire article. Was everyone at the NYT asleep at the switch around 1999/2000? In a wired, digitally archived world, how could collective amnesia wipe out the privacy disaster foisted on an unsuspecting public courtesy of Radio Shack and trusted entities like Wired? Digital:Convergence, Inc., the original creator/designer of the :CueCat, is long gone, with its patents picked up by LV Partners, a "technology portfolio management" company.
Perhaps the new codes create fewer privacy concerns. The original :CueCat was doomed because devices each had unique IDs (that were quickly hacked, destroying the value of the system to merchandisers). Even with at least three sources for the codes, I don't see how the situation is all that different. All the codes still run through those central servers and generate the same demographic data -- and mobile phones have even more personally identifying information than a :CueCat did.
UPDATE: It seems that I needed to do a little more research... as NotAMonkey helpfully noted in the comments, NeoMedia licensed its patents to Digital:Convergence back in 2000 (when :CueCat was being launched). That information is not necessarily the end of the story, but it does eliminate some of my original speculations. To the extent that Digital:Convergence secured its own patents for "improvements" to the NeoMedia patents (and there wasn't a license-back provision drafted in 2000), there could still be a patent mess waiting in the wings -- but that turn of events is a little less likely than I'd originally expected.
Perhaps LV Partners already has licensed out the relevant technology and is reaping the financial rewards. If not, I'd expect a slew of lawsuits to start raining down on Qode / NeoMedia Technologies, QR Code / Denso Wave, and Semacode -- the technological overlap between :CueCat and these new codes is blazingly obvious to me as a somewhat casual observer.
Categories
Technology4 Comments
Leave a comment
Hello,
Actually DIgital Convergence LICENSED the IP from NeoMedia for the Cut Cat,
Read about it here: http://neom.com/press_releases/2000/20001019.jsp
So you see, whatever patents LV got from Digital Convergence hold zero sway over the connecting the physical world to the internet.
@ NotAMonkey:
Thanks for the information -- I've updated the entry accordingly.
I'm still curious to see how the privacy aspects get worked out, however. Internet privacy has become a much hotter issue in the intervening 6-7 years, and the current implementations of these enhanced codes still rely heavily on the same gadget-savvy public who led the popular uprising against :CueCat in the first place.
Thanks for posting this. I didn't know what happened to the CueCat and even went to a suburban Radio Shack last year known for having old stock to see if I could get one to use as a UPC scanner (no CueCats, but if you need storage boxes for 5.25" floppies...).
fyi using the MacBook iSight camera as a barcode scanner (as promoted by Delicious Library) is highly overrated and barely works. I tried for a few days before my ill fated Radio Shack trip and then switching to typing in the UPC codes
NeoMedia’s mobile code reading platform qode is making tremendous strides in Europe as well as here in North America. With a great showing at CTIA, tremendous media coverage from the New York Times, and their involvement with the Mobile Codes Consortium, qode is on its way to becoming the code-agnostic universal reader with its soon to be released upgrade version capable of reading UPC, Aztec, Datamatrix, and QR codes.
Best,
Sean
http://streetstylz.blogspot.com/